A Timeless Treasure: An Italianate Rowhouse at 624 South Street, Lafayette – $450,000

A Timeless Treasure: An Italianate Rowhouse at 624 South Street, Lafayette

In the heart of downtown Lafayette, where history and modern life intersect, stands an extraordinary Italianate rowhouse that offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of Indiana’s architectural legacy.

Priced at $450,000, 624 South Street is more than a residence—it is a preserved landmark that tells the story of Victorian craftsmanship, thoughtful design, and enduring elegance. Built in 1890 by Ira Howe for his family, this distinguished home is the largest in its historic row and the only one to feature an attached carriage house, setting it apart as a truly unique offering.

From the moment you arrive, the home’s presence is unmistakable. The façade reflects the confidence and refinement of the late 19th century, highlighted by grand double front doors adorned with original etched glass imported from France.

These doors not only provide striking curb appeal but also serve as a tangible reminder of a time when fine materials and skilled artisanship were paramount. Along the front sidewalk, an original iron hitching post, still standing proudly in place, offers a rare and charming glimpse into everyday Victorian life—a detail seldom found intact in modern urban settings.

Stepping inside, the home immediately immerses you in authentic period character. As a protected historic landmark, 624 South Street has retained an impressive array of original features that have been carefully preserved. Ornate plaster moldings, hand-crafted ceiling medallions, and grand fireplaces anchor the interiors with elegance and warmth.

Original light fixtures and lanterns hang gracefully from the ceilings, casting a soft glow that enhances the home’s timeless atmosphere. At the center of it all rises a grand staircase, both functional and dramatic, serving as a sculptural focal point that reflects the home’s stately proportions.

The main level offers a thoughtful balance between historic formality and everyday livability. The informal kitchen, rich with character, features emerald stained-glass accents that filter natural light in jewel-toned hues.

Above, a matching ornate tin ceiling adds texture and visual interest, making the space feel both intimate and special. Adjacent to the kitchen is a classic butler’s pantry, a hallmark of refined Victorian homes, which connects seamlessly to a back staircase—once used by household staff and now a charming architectural feature that enhances the home’s authenticity.

Ascending to the upper level, the home’s private spaces continue the narrative of craftsmanship and thoughtful design. The residence includes three bedrooms and two full bathrooms, with each bedroom connected by built-in storage wardrobes—a distinctive feature that reflects 19th-century ingenuity long before the era of walk-in closets.

These built-ins not only maximize space but also serve as beautiful, functional reminders of the home’s original layout and purpose. The bathrooms, while updated for comfort, remain in harmony with the historic character of the house.

One of the most enchanting aspects of 624 South Street lies just beyond its walls. At the rear of the property, a whimsical, gated private garden offers a peaceful retreat from the bustle of downtown life.

Enclosed by a brick wall accented with decorative iron details, the garden feels like a hidden sanctuary—perfect for quiet mornings, intimate gatherings, or simply enjoying the changing seasons. This outdoor space enhances the home’s livability while maintaining the sense of privacy rarely found in an urban setting.

Adding to the home’s practicality is the attached carriage house, now serving as a one-car attached garage. With one total parking space, this feature is a significant asset in downtown Lafayette, where off-street parking is both valuable and convenient. The carriage house further underscores the home’s historic roots while meeting modern needs.

Location is another defining advantage of this remarkable property. Situated in the heart of downtown Lafayette, 624 South Street places you just steps away from shopping, dining, and entertainment.

Whether enjoying local restaurants, cultural events, or the vibrancy of city life, everything is within easy reach—yet the home itself remains a serene and dignified retreat from the outside world.

As a broker-owned property, this residence represents a rare chance to acquire a meticulously preserved historic home with both architectural significance and everyday functionality. Italianate rowhouses of this caliber, especially those with original features intact and an attached carriage house, seldom come to market.

In a time when new construction dominates the housing landscape, 624 South Street stands as a testament to enduring design and craftsmanship.

It offers not just a place to live, but an opportunity to steward a piece of Lafayette’s history—where every etched glass panel, plaster molding, and iron detail tells a story. For those who appreciate heritage, character, and timeless beauty, this extraordinary residence is truly one of a kind.

FROM ZILLOW