Charming 1840 Farmhouse on 1.7 Acres in Canandaigua — A Historic Country Retreat With Endless Potential
Step into the timeless charm of this 1840 farmhouse, a beautifully situated country home resting on 1.7 peaceful acres in the heart of Canandaigua. With 4 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and 2,004 sq ft of interior space, this property offers the character of historic architecture paired with the room, layout, and rural setting modern buyers love. From the moment you arrive, the long, quiet lot and the inviting front porch set the tone for relaxed country living, giving you the perfect place to unwind, sip morning coffee, and enjoy the breathtaking sunrise views that greet each new day.
This farmhouse offers a warm, welcoming layout that blends practicality with old-world charm. The first floor includes two bedrooms, making it ideal for multi-generational living, guest accommodations, or creating a private home office. A spacious first-floor laundry room, complete with abundant storage, adds convenience and everyday functionality—features that are rare to find in older homes unless they’ve been thoughtfully updated. The second floor hosts two additional bedrooms, giving everyone space to spread out comfortably.
Stepping outside, you’ll find a property designed to support both relaxation and recreation. A charming side deck provides the perfect spot for outdoor dining, grilling, or simply enjoying warm summer evenings. The fenced-in yard adds peace of mind for pets and children while also offering privacy from the surrounding landscape. For car enthusiasts, hobbyists, or those needing extra storage, the detached 2-car garage offers flexibility and convenience.
The deep 1.7-acre lot extends far behind the home, offering ample space to garden, plant fruit trees, establish an outdoor entertainment area, or simply enjoy the feeling of owning a private country retreat. The land provides both open areas and natural buffers, making the property feel much larger than it appears from the road. It’s the kind of space that invites imagination—whether you dream of hosting gatherings, expanding the outdoor living area, or just relaxing in total peace and quiet.
One of the most appealing features of this property is the workshop area located at the back of the home. This space, filled with potential and ready for restoration, presents an extraordinary opportunity for hobbyists, creatives, or anyone who’s ever dreamed of having a dedicated place to work on projects. Whether you envision a woodworking shop, an art studio, a fitness room, a music space, or a recreational retreat, this workshop can be transformed to fit your unique needs. With some repairs and personal vision, it can become one of the most treasured parts of the property.
Like many historic homes from the 19th century, this farmhouse does require some work and updating. However, the structure itself carries the charm and character that modern homes rarely replicate—wide porches, original details, and a sense of history you can’t build today. For the right buyer, the opportunity here is enormous. With thoughtful renovations, this home could become a stunning blend of classic farmhouse charm and modern comfort. Whether you’re restoring it to its former glory, updating it to reflect a more contemporary style, or creating a blend of old and new, the possibilities are truly endless.
While the setting feels perfectly peaceful, this property is far from isolated. It is located just minutes from everything Canandaigua has to offer, making it ideal for those who want a rural lifestyle without sacrificing convenience. The area is known for its natural beauty, offering countless opportunities for outdoor recreation. Residents can enjoy swimming, boating, and fishing on the sparkling waters of Canandaigua Lake—one of the Finger Lakes’ most popular destinations. From warm summer days on the water to the colorful fall foliage that surrounds the region, every season brings something to enjoy.
Entertainment options are also abundant. The property is just a short drive from CMAC, the Constellation Brands–Marvin Sands Performing Arts Center, a beloved venue known for concerts, festivals, and events featuring nationally recognized performers. Whether you’re a fan of live music, outdoor amphitheater experiences, or cultural events, CMAC provides world-class entertainment close to home.
For dining and nightlife, Canandaigua offers a vibrant mix of restaurants, cafés, wineries, and breweries. From waterfront dining to cozy pubs and local tasting rooms, the area is a hotspot for food and drink lovers. Shops and boutiques line the charming downtown streets, offering everything from antiques and artisan goods to modern essentials. If you love exploring, browsing, and discovering hidden gems, you’ll find plenty of places to enjoy.
In the winter months, the region transforms into a playground for cold-weather activities. Skiing, snowshoeing, winter hiking, and seasonal festivals offer endless fun. Nearby ski resorts and trails make it easy to enjoy outdoor adventures without venturing far from home.
The location strikes a perfect balance between privacy, charm, and convenience—something buyers truly value. Whether you’re looking for a full-time residence, a weekend getaway, or a long-term investment in the highly desirable Finger Lakes region, this farmhouse offers exceptional potential for a wide range of lifestyles.
The opportunity to own a property like this—filled with history, space, character, and land—is increasingly rare. With 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and over 2,000 sq ft, the home provides generous room for families, hosting guests, or creating dedicated office and hobby spaces. The 1.7-acre lot offers privacy and outdoor living opportunities that are hard to find close to town. And the nearby attractions make the location nearly unbeatable.
Whether you imagine renovating it into a showpiece farmhouse, creating a peaceful country retreat, or restoring it in a way that honors its original character, this property is ready to welcome a new owner who sees the potential within its walls. With vision and care, this 1840 home can shine once again—beautifully blending the charm of the past with the comfort of modern life.
Delayed negotiations are set for 11/21 at 2:00 PM, giving interested buyers time to explore the possibilities, imagine the lifestyle, and appreciate the unique opportunity this property represents.
If you’re seeking a peaceful setting, room to grow, and a home with authentic character in the heart of Canandaigua, this historic farmhouse may be the perfect match. Embrace the charm, see the potential, and make this timeless property your next chapter.
Listed on Zillow
